Columbus Crew's team badge New York City's team badge

Columbus Crew v New York City : Major League Soccer match betting preview, prediction and odds

Lower.com Field, Columbus

Columbus Crew and their boss Wilfried Nancy will be looking to get one over on Pascal Gastien and his New York City side on Saturday night, as the pair go head to head at the Lower.com Field in the Major League Soccer. Our predictions are based on complex statistical analysis of each side, across seventeen of the main markets. Data shown and the odds are unique to each market, and head-to-head statistics are included across the board.

This match has now expired. Kickoff has all of the best football predictions for you to choose from, for all Major League Soccer Predictions. Kickoff constantly updates all 17 football betting markets to analyse and predict football scores – whether you choose football accumulator tips, both teams to score (BTTS tips), correct score, or if you are looking for free football tips – then make sure to sign up to Kickoff.co.uk today.

Columbus Crew's next match is v DC United at 23:30 on Saturday 29th March
New York City's next match is v Atlanta at 23:30 on Saturday 29th March
The last American Major League Soccer meeting between Columbus and NY City was on Saturday 22nd March 2025
American Major League Soccer
March 22nd 2025
Columbus 0
0 NY City
 
COL
NYC
Shots On
5
Shots Off
11
2
Corners
10
Possession
60%
40%
Fouls
9
11
 
ColumbusNY City
 
E. Bush
M. Herrera Mansilla
Y. Cheberko
C. Ruvalcaba Perez (T. Brown 73')
D. Jones
A. Jackson (C. Mrowka 66')
D. Nagbe
D. Rossi Marachlian
S. Zawadzki
D. Chambost
J. Russell-Rowe
F. Matthew
B. Risa
T. Martins Bueno
K. O'Toole
M. Ilenčič
(J. Shore 35') K. Alexander Parks
J. Haak
M. Moralez
(S. Garfield-Reid 73') M. Bakrar
(M. Carrizo Ballesteros 73') H. Wolf
(A. Ojeda 58') J. Fernández

Best Tip: Over 1.5 goals

Our prediction for Saturday's game is over 2.5 goals, meaning that we expect Columbus and NY City to score 3 goals or more between them during the standard 90 mins. 2 goals or less would mean it's a losing tip but, with statistics below suggesting both teams have goals in them, we think it looks like a great bet.

In-Play
Win / Draw / Win
Over / Under 1.5 Goals
Over / Under 2.5 Goals
Over / Under 3.5 Goals
Win To Nil
Both Teams To Score
Correct Score
Both Teams To Score & Result
Double Chance
Half Time / Full Time
Over / Under 0.5 Goals
Over / Under 4.5 Goals
Over / Under 5.5 Goals
Draw No Bet
Team To Score First
If you’re looking for a winner in this match, we think Columbus are the most likely. Our predictive algorithm gives them a 43% chance of victory, and the bookies have them at a best price of 1.80.

Checkout the hundreds of tips picked but our top win/draw/win tipsters

Change odds
Predictions Add Bet365 Coral
Columbus
43%
5/4
35%
7/10
5%
Draw
24%
12/5
11%
13/5
3%
NY City
33%
11/5
36%
3/1
11%
Draw 1-1
11%
11/2
13%
6/1
7%
Columbus 2-1
9%
8/1
6%
7/1
Columbus 1-0
8%
17/27/1
6%
NY City 2-1
8%
11/1
20%
11/1
8%
NY City 1-0
7%
11/1
37%
12/1
13%
Columbus 2-0
6%
11/1
26%
8/1
Draw 2-2
6%
11/1
8%
11/1
Draw 0-0
5%
11/1
20%
11/1
8%
NY City 2-0
5%
16/1
41%
20/1
9%
Columbus 3-1
5%
16/1
42%
11/1
9%
NY City 3-1
4%
22/1
32%
25/1
Columbus 3-0
3%
20/1
62%
12/1
8%
Columbus 3-2
3%
22/1
10%
16/1
NY City 3-2
3%
28/1
15%
25/1
NY City 3-0
2%
33/1
33%
33/1
17%
Over 2.5 Goals
57%
3/4
11%
8/13
5%
Under 2.5 Goals
43%
21/20
13%
23/20
7%
Home 1st Goal
50%
8/11
20%
-
Away 1st Goal
47%
5/4
18%
-
No 1st Goal
3%
11/1
20%
-
BTTS - Yes
60%
8/13
3%
8/13
1%
BTTS - No
40%
6/5
2%
23/20
2%
BTTS - Home Win
23%
3/1
29%
11/5
10%
BTTS - Draw
19%
3/1
11%
18/5
BTTS - Away Win
18%
9/2
31%
6/1
7%
Home/draw
67%
4/11
16%
2/9
3%
Away/draw
57%
8/13
25%
1/1
9%
Home/away
76%
3/10
4%
1/4
Over 1.5 Goals
80%
2/9
4%
1/5
2%
Under 1.5 Goals
20%
3/1
20%
16/5
7%
Over 3.5 Goals
35%
7/4
16%
6/4
9%
Under 3.5 Goals
65%
2/5
9%
10/21
3%
Over 4.5 Goals
18%
9/2
27%
17/5
10%
Under 4.5 Goals
82%
1/7
5%
2/11
3%
Over 5.5 Goals
8%
10/1
38%
15/2
13%
Under 5.5 Goals
92%
1/20
3%
1/16
2%
Over 0.5 Goals
95%
1/25
1%
1/33
Under 0.5 Goals
5%
11/1
20%
11/1
8%
Home DNB
60%
8/13
30%
1/3
6%
Away DNB
50%
6/5
41%
21/10
14%
Columbus win to nil
20%
10/3
27%
-
NY City win to nil
15%
5/1
40%
-
Columbus / Columbus
26%
13/5
38%
17/10
8%
Columbus / NY City
3%
25/1
24%
28/1
15%
Columbus / Draw
6%
12/112/1
Draw / Columbus
16%
9/2
16%
18/5
2%
Draw / NY City
10%
6/1
30%
8/1
10%
Draw / Draw
15%
9/2
15%
19/4
4%
NY City / Columbus
4%
22/1
21%
18/1
NY City / NY City
14%
15/4
37%
6/1
7%
NY City / Draw
6%
12/1
13%
12/1
13%
Match Predictor Pro
Your ultimate betting assistant
Try it now
Win / draw / win form
Columbus 6TH
20 league games
Home
Overall
Goals: Scored
42
Conceded
24
Games: Scored
16 / 20
Conceded
12 / 20
Clean sheets
8 / 20
Failed to score
4 / 20
Won
11
Draw
5
L
4
HOME FORM Win / Draw / Win
Columbus0 - 0Houston
Columbus4 - 2Chicago
Columbus0 - 1NY Red Bulls
Columbus4 - 0New England
Columbus3 - 2Philadelphia
Columbus2 - 3Miami
Columbus4 - 3Orlando
Columbus0 - 4Seattle
Columbus4 - 2NY City
Columbus1 - 1Charlotte
Columbus4 - 0Toronto
Columbus2 - 0Nashville
Columbus4 - 0Sporting KC
Columbus1 - 2Cincinnati
Columbus0 - 0Montreal
Columbus2 - 2Portland
Columbus1 - 1DC United
Columbus3 - 0NY Red Bulls
Columbus2 - 1Chicago
Columbus1 - 0Atlanta
Goals: Scored
40
Conceded
28
Games: Scored
16 / 20
Conceded
14 / 20
Clean sheets
6 / 20
Failed to score
4 / 20
Won
10
Draw
6
L
4
OVERALL FORM Win / Draw / Win
AColumbus1 - 1San Diego
HColumbus0 - 0Houston
AColumbus1 - 0New England
HColumbus4 - 2Chicago
AColumbus2 - 2NY Red Bulls
HColumbus0 - 1NY Red Bulls
AColumbus3 - 2NY Red Bulls
HColumbus4 - 0New England
HColumbus3 - 2Philadelphia
HColumbus2 - 3Miami
AColumbus2 - 2DC United
HColumbus4 - 3Orlando
AColumbus2 - 0Toronto
AColumbus0 - 0Cincinnati
HColumbus0 - 4Seattle
HColumbus4 - 2NY City
AColumbus1 - 0Philadelphia
AColumbus1 - 2Atlanta
HColumbus1 - 1Charlotte
AColumbus5 - 1LAFC
NY City 8TH
20 league games
Away
Overall
Goals: Scored
21
Conceded
27
Games: Scored
11 / 20
Conceded
17 / 20
Clean sheets
3 / 20
Failed to score
9 / 20
W
4
Draw
7
Lost
9
AWAY FORM Win / Draw / Win
LAFC1 - 0NY City
Miami2 - 2NY City
Cincinnati0 - 0NY City
Cincinnati1 - 0NY City
Montreal2 - 0NY City
NY Red Bulls1 - 5NY City
DC United1 - 1NY City
Columbus4 - 2NY City
Orlando1 - 1NY City
Atlanta2 - 2NY City
Chicago0 - 0NY City
Austin2 - 1NY City
Nashville1 - 0NY City
LA Galaxy2 - 0NY City
New England0 - 1NY City
Philadelphia1 - 2NY City
Toronto2 - 3NY City
Miami1 - 1NY City
Cincinnati1 - 0NY City
Saint Louis City2 - 0NY City
Goals: Scored
30
Conceded
31
Games: Scored
14 / 20
Conceded
18 / 20
Clean sheets
2 / 20
Failed to score
6 / 20
Won
6
Draw
8
Lost
6
OVERALL FORM Win / Draw / Win
HNY City2 - 1New England
HNY City2 - 1Orlando
ANY City0 - 1LAFC
ANY City2 - 2Miami
HNY City0 - 2NY Red Bulls
ANY City0 - 0Cincinnati
HNY City3 - 1Cincinnati
ANY City0 - 1Cincinnati
ANY City0 - 2Montreal
HNY City3 - 1Nashville
HNY City3 - 2Cincinnati
ANY City5 - 1NY Red Bulls
HNY City1 - 1Miami
HNY City1 - 5Philadelphia
ANY City1 - 1DC United
ANY City2 - 4Columbus
HNY City2 - 2Chicago
ANY City1 - 1Orlando
ANY City2 - 2Atlanta
ANY City0 - 0Chicago
Win / draw / win head to head (H2H)
8
Columbus have not lost to NY City in 8 consecutive home league meetings
League games at Columbus since 2018
Columbus
NY City
Goals: Scored
18
10
Games: Scored
8 / 8
7 / 8
Clean sheets
1 / 8
0 / 8
COL
6
D
2
FIXTURE HISTORY AT Columbus
Columbus4 - 2
Draw1 - 1Draw
Columbus3 - 2
Columbus2 - 1
Columbus3 - 1
Columbus1 - 0
Draw2 - 2Draw
Columbus2 - 1
League games at NY City since 2018
NY City
Columbus
Goals: Scored
14
7
Games: Scored
8 / 8
4 / 8
Clean sheets
4 / 8
0 / 8
COL
2
D
1
NYC
5
FIXTURE HISTORY AT NY City
2 - 3Columbus
Draw1 - 1Draw
NY City2 - 0
NY City4 - 1
1 - 2Columbus
NY City1 - 0
NY City1 - 0
NY City2 - 0
Goal Statistics
Columbus 6th NY City 8th
Kickoff prediction
Kickoff prediction
1.9
goals
1.1
goals
Scoring probability
Scoring probability
0
20%
1
32%
2
26%
3
14%
4+
8%
There is a 80% probability that Columbus will score 1 or more goals
0
25%
1
35%
2
24%
3
11%
4+
There is a 60% probability that NY City will score no more than 1 goal
 
20 home / away league games
20 home / away league games
+7
Columbus’s goalscoring at home has been inline with predictions
-17
NY City have scored 17% fewer goals when away than predicted
2.1
average goals scored
1.1
average goals scored
1.2
conceded
1.4
conceded
 
Attack defence ratings
Major League Soccer - 2025/2025 season
https://api.kickoff.co.uk/v1/fixture/290823/accaPanel/formStats/marketCode/FULL
Columbus
PG (predicted goals)
NY City
1.9
1.1
Attack rating
9%
better
COL
NYC
view stats
Games scored3
3
Failed to score1
1
Scored first2
1
Goals scored6
6
Avg. goals scored1.5
1.5
Avg. shots per game7
10
Avg. shots per goal5
6
Conversion rate for21
16
Avg. XG for1.1
1.2
KickOff rating
+9%
Defence rating
47%
better
COL
NYC
view stats
Games conceded2
4
Clean sheets2
0
Conceded first1
3
Goals conceded3
5
Avg. goals conceded0.8
1.3
Avg. shots/game conceded7
8
Avg. shots/goal conceded9
6
Conversion rate against12%
17%
Avg. XG against1.2
1.2
KickOff rating
+47%

Columbus v NY City Major League Soccer lLine ups will show here when available.

Columbus Major League Soccer squad statistics 2025
Overall
Attack
Defence
Most startsMost goalsMost assistsMost cards
5212
Y CheberkoJ Russell-RoweD JonesS Zawadzki
Line-upAppserancesgoalsAssistscards
E Bush GLK1
-
A Herrera DEF4
-
Y Cheberko DEF5
-
S Zawadzki DEF5
2
-
D Jones DEF31
-
C. Ruvalcaba Perez MID1
-
D Nagbe MID5
-
D Chambost MID5
1
-
A Jackson FWD5
-
J Russell-Rowe FWD52
-
D Rossi FWD52
1
-
Subs
T. Brown DEF1
-
A Sejdic MID
-
D Jones MID
-
C. Mrowka MID1
-
O. Presthus MID
-
L Lappalainen FWD
-
NY City Major League Soccer squad statistics 2025
Overall
Attack
Defence
Most startsMost goalsMost assistsMost cards
5112
M FreeseM IleničM MoralezK O'Toole
Line-upAppserancesgoalsAssistscards
M Freese GLK5
1
-
M Ilenič DEF51
-
T Martins DEF4
-
B Risa DEF4
-
K O'Toole DEF4
1
1
K Parks MID5
2
-
J Haak MID5
-
M Moralez MID51
1
-
J Fernández FWD511
-
M. Bakrar FWD5
1
-
H Wolf FWD511
-
Subs
G Ranjitsingh GLK
-
A Rando GLK
-
S Tanasijević DEF3
1
-
P. Amponsah DEF
-
M. Carrizo Ballesteros MID1
-
J. Shore MID4
1
-
P. Molinari MID
-
A Ojeda FWD5
-